Top 5 Restaurant Loyalty Programs in 2025Increase Customer Retention
Restaurant reward programs have become a significant game-changer for restaurants looking to increase repeat business and enhance customer engagement. The right restaurant loyalty software can upsell and improve your frequent visits and manage the average order value.
At Clavaa, we truly value the competitive nature of the restaurant industry. Our proficient research shows that integrating a loyalty program can boost frequency and visits by up to 35% and could increase purchases by 20%.
Right down below, we are presenting you with an in-depth tour and comparison of the top restaurant loyalty software providers, helping users to see their reviews, features, and overall impact on the business.
Top 5 Loyalty App Providers for Restaurants
What is a Restaurant Loyalty Program?
With more than 660,000 dining facilities in the U.S. alone, having distinguishing features requires more than good food. A restaurant loyalty program is made to repeat and reward customers with great benefits, encouraging them to choose your very own establishment over different competitors. Such restaurant discount programs can range from simple punch cards at coffee shops to the most advanced, driven AI-based reward systems for multi-chain restaurants.
By giving away such perks as discounts and exclusive deals, restaurants can certainly increase their lifetime value, customer retention, and sales volume.
Watch: Our Favorite Video On Restaurant Loyalty Programs
Why Are Restaurant Loyalty Programs Essential?
Every smart restaurant owner knows a secret hack of offering a certain benefit that drives customers back to them. Here are some of the reasons explaining why such loyalty programs are too good to pass up.
Boosts Customer Retention
An average American eats out six days a week, and competition for strong customer loyalty is a major plus and a weak point for the majority of businesses.
Research and reports show that loyal customers are likely to spend 33% more on orders and visit their favorite restaurant chain 1.5 times more than those who aren't members. A well-laid-out customer rewards program for restaurants can potentially boost customer retention by 23%, making sure the loyal ones return instead of going for another competitor.
Enhances Customer Engagement
There is no doubt that a well-structured loyalty program fosters an emotional bond between customers and the brands.
By simply personalizing rewards, restaurants can increase customer engagement rates, which can climb up to 40-50%.
Provides a Competitive Edge
Large chains invest 11% of their annual budgets in loyalty programs compared to the 3% for independent restaurants, ensuring a loyalty program can definitely level up the playing field.
So, giving away some tips, promotions, and data-driven strategies can give you a certain edge over implementing your strategies.
Studies show loyal customers spend 33% more per order and visit 1.5× more frequently than non-members. This isn't just feel-good fluff—engaged customers are 7× more likely to respond positively to promotional offers.
The restaurant experience is enhanced when customers feel recognized and valued
Key Benefits of Implementing a Loyalty Program
Implementing certain strategies in your business can bring in various advantages if taken on a broader spectrum, and here are some of them you need to keep in mind.
Increased Revenue
Patrons are likely to spend $20-$10 more per given transaction.
Competitive Advantage
Loyalty programs fill in the gap, which increases the customer's retention by 23% on average.
Customer Insights
Top restaurant rewards programs help to optimize promotions and pricing accordingly to the customer's preferences. Even on special occasions such as birthdays, they are likely to get more certain incentives, such as 5-10% off on their food or getting free birthday cake.
To discover the best loyalty platforms available today, read our detailed guide on the 5 Best Loyalty Platform Providers in 2025.
Clavaa
The Emerging Innovation LeaderRevolutionary Approach to Restaurant Loyalty Software
Clavaa has renovated customer loyalty by simply combining payment and instant rewards into a seamless platform, unlike the traditional ones that completely rely on third-party applications. Calvaa's seamless mobile wallet diminishes the transaction fees, sending those savings directly to the customer's reward center. Early users have noticed a striking 40% increase in the repetitive visits, making this restaurant loyalty program with cashback even more rejuvenating!
Market Positioning
Being a completely new name in the loyalty industry, Clavaa has somehow managed to gain attention due to its innovative cost-reduction approach. While third-party reviews are strictly restricted, early results and certain case studies indicate how potent this can be. For the restaurants that are struggling with customers' repetitive visits and payment processing, Clavaa is an absolute boon, which not only brings back the customers but also improves the overall bottom line.
Certain Advantages To Look At
Certain Disadvantages To Talk About
Square Loyalty
Integrated POS Loyalty Solution
The Square Loyalty program is an all-in-one customer retention solution that seamlessly integrates with the Square POS ecosystem without any fancy frills. Purposely made for restaurants, cafes, and businesses with quick service, it enables effortless program management that doesn't need any additional hardware or software. With its intuitive and responsive interface and data-driven approach, Square Loyalty keeps restaurant and customer engagement on time.
Market Position & Future Outlook
As a highly anticipated name in the POS industry, Square Loyalty offers a stream down and accessible options for small to large scale restaurants, it may lacks on the other hand with some of the advanced capabilities of a professional solution, it's in-depth POS integration makes it a perfect choice for multiple businesses who are looking forward to a seamless loyalty program.
Advantages
Disadvantages
FiveStars
Universal Loyalty Network
FiveStars is a globally known loyalty program platform that is designed to help independent restaurants and small businesses compete with the big fish. By offering a multi-level approach to customer engagement, FiveStars enables businesses to make repetitive in-store visits, SMS-based, or app-based rewards.
Market Stats & Future
Feedback from various users has indicated a potential for FiveStars to have a far-flung revenue impact; some businesses have even reported $100,000 in additional revenue. As time goes on, we can see that FiveStars fosters immersive customer relationships for independent restaurants; its ability to drive engagement above transactions plays it as a fairly good advantage.
Key Advantages
Considerations
Implementation Note
To maximize the benefits of FiveStars, restaurants should fully integrate the loyalty program with their customer service workflow. Training staff to promote the program and ensuring the rewards are compelling enough to drive repeat visits can significantly improve results.
Punchh
Enterprise-Grade Loyalty Platform
This is one of the most anticipated loyalty and CRM platforms; Punch is reluctant to outsource to large names and franchises such as Taco Bell and Pizza Hut by providing its sophisticated programs for customer-based incentives, personal promotions, and marketing campaigns led by AI.
Advanced Capabilities
Punchh is indeed one of the recognized names when it comes to enterprise-level loyalty solutions. By simply offering an unparalleled approach with data-driven marketing capabilities, large-scale restaurants can benefit from its highly advanced tools.
Advantages
Potential Drawbacks
Implementation Insights
For restaurants considering Punchh, it's important to evaluate whether your operation has the scale to justify the investment. The platform delivers exceptional results for larger operations but requires dedicated resources to manage effectively.
- Best suited for multi-location restaurants and chains
- Consider your technical resources for implementation
- Plan for staff training on the platform
- Evaluate ROI based on your customer volume
Paytronix
Comprehensive Restaurant Experience Platform
Paytronix is an AI-driven loyalty program platform that successfully integrates with the CRM and POS system to give customers an immersive retention experience. It is widely used by both independent and large restaurant chains to optimize their different retention strategies.
Data-Driven Approach
Paytronix marks itself as a top-tier loyalty solution for many data-driven restaurant brands. Its AI incorporation provides a fairly decent edge for better results, although pricing may be a little hectic for small businesses. However, for larger chains, it is somewhat too optimal.
Certain advantages
Key Considerations To Look At
Best For Large Restaurants
Paytronix is particularly well-suited for larger restaurant operations that:
- Have multiple locations or franchise operations
- Want to leverage customer data for personalized marketing
- Need comprehensive analytics to drive business decisions
- Can invest in advanced loyalty technology for long-term growth
Choosing the Right Loyalty Solution
Tailoring Loyalty Programs to Your Business
Opting for the right restaurant loyalty program completely depends on the uniqueness and certain goals of a business. With major solutions such as Clavaa or Square Loyalty on board, cost-effective options for smaller businesses are always on the go. By simply leveraging customer insights, automation, and strategizing rewards, restaurants will not only enhance their customer loyalty but also boost revenue and longevity.
The Evolving Landscape of Restaurant Loyalty
As technology grows, businesses are more likely to frown over such programs, eventually leading to a certain advantage to an increasingly competitive restaurant industry.
Related Articles
Need More Information?
Compare detailed features, pricing, and customer reviews for each platform.
Compare All SolutionsReady to Get Started?
Schedule a consultation to find the right loyalty solution for your restaurant.
Book a ConsultationReady to grow your business?
Join thousands of businesses using Clavaa to boost customer loyalty
Start using Clavaa
Get set up in minutes and start growing your business with integrated payments and loyalty.
No credit card required
Free payment processing with Clavaa
Full access to marketing tools
Talk to our team
Get personalized guidance on how Clavaa can help your business grow.
15-minute discovery call
Live product tour
Customized growth strategy
Join thousands of businesses already using Clavaa to boost their revenue